Letters Never Sent #3: A Most Tragic Breakup

Dear Old Love,

I never thought we’d end up here.

After everything we’ve been through together, I always imagined we’d have more time. I knew this day would come eventually, but knowing something is inevitable doesn’t make it any easier when it finally happens.

We’ve been together for three, maybe four years now. Honestly, I’ve lost count. I just know you’ve been there through so much of my life, and the thought of having to move on without you feels wrong.

You were never particularly fancy. You weren’t expensive, and you certainly weren’t perfect. But I didn’t care about any of that. From the moment I found you, something just felt right. I took one look at you and knew you were coming home with me.

And for the longest time, we were happy.

We went everywhere together. Work, shopping, little adventures, and countless ordinary days that probably wouldn’t mean much to anyone else. You were there for all of it. No complaints, no demands, no unnecessary drama. Just the quiet comfort of knowing I could always count on you.

I think that’s what I’ll miss the most. The comfort.

You fit into my life so perfectly that I stopped imagining what it would be like without you. I never had to question whether you were right for me. You just were.

But lately, things have been falling apart.

At first, I tried to ignore it. A little wear and tear didn’t seem like a good enough reason to throw away everything we’d built together. Nobody stays perfect forever, and I certainly wasn’t about to abandon you just because you were showing your age.

I told myself we could make it work.

Then things started getting worse.

You were coming apart at the seams. There were cracks in places I didn’t even know could crack. I kept pretending everything was fine, even when it became painfully obvious that we were holding on to something that wasn’t going to last.

And the worst part?

You still fit me perfectly.

Do you have any idea how unfair that is?

How am I supposed to walk away from something that still feels so right, even when it’s clearly falling apart?

I suppose I should’ve known better than to get this attached. Especially considering how we met.

A church yard sale.

Two dollars.

TWO. WHOLE. DOLLARS.

That’s all I paid for you.

And somehow, you became my favorite pair of shoes I’ve ever owned.

Yes. Shoes.

My beloved, dirty, falling-apart, desperately-needing-to-be-retired shoes.

You have holes. Your soles are separating. Your insides are falling apart, and I’m fairly certain you’re being held together by stubbornness, memories, and whatever tiny bit of glue hasn’t completely given up on life.

And yet, every morning, I still want to put you on.

I don’t WANT new shoes. I don’t want to spend weeks breaking in some stiff, uncomfortable replacements that don’t understand my feet the way you do.

I want YOU.

Unfortunately, you’ve reached the point where wearing you much longer might qualify as an extreme sport.

So, against my will, I’ve been forced to find someone new.

And I hate it.

The new pair doesn’t feel the same. They haven’t been through anything with me. They don’t know my routines, my favorite places, or how many times I’ve said, “These shoes are about done,” before putting you right back on anyway.

They haven’t earned my loyalty.

You have.

But I suppose three or four years is a pretty impressive run for something I found at a yard sale for less than the price of a candy bar.

You gave me more than my money’s worth. You were comfortable, dependable, and apparently determined to stay with me until you physically couldn’t anymore.

And, well, you’ve certainly accomplished that last part.

So I guess this is goodbye.

Thank you for every mile, every long day, and every ordinary moment you carried me through. Thank you for being the best two dollars I’ve ever spent.

I know it’s time to let you go.

I just wish you’d stop fitting so perfectly while falling apart so spectacularly.

With love, heartbreak, and a deeply unreasonable amount of emotional attachment,

The woman who still isn’t ready to throw you away. 🖤

Comments

Leave a Reply